unofficial cm page


UMs Disfellowship Bishop For Campaigning For Homosexuality

October 12, 1999

Mr. Jack M. Tuell
816 South 216th Street
Des Moines, Washington 98198

Dear Mr. Tuell:

When I was a seminary student, your volume on The Book of Discipline was required reading. I recall being impressed by the readability of your book. You are clearly a person well versed in the order and discipline of the Church. So it was with sadness that I read your letter to lay and clergy delegates to the 2000 General Conference. In that letter, you urge the delegates to overturn legislation passed by the 1996 General Conference which prohibits the performance of "homosexual unions" by United Methodist ministers and in United Methodist churches.

This action by you, a retired Bishop of The United Methodist Church, is unconscionable. By writing this letter and affixing your signature to it, you have disqualified yourself from the episcopacy. Your action has undermined your personal and professional credibility, as well as the overall integrity of the Council of Bishops.

Your concern for "fairness" with regard to pastors who wish to "minister" to persons involved in homosexual relationships is misdirected. There is "unfairness" and "injustice" within our denomination today. However, it is most often directed against those pastors who seek to be faithful to Scripture and "to contend for the faith that was once for all entrusted to the saints" (Jude 3). I do not hear you or any other "bishop" speaking out on behalf of those pastors who cannot in good conscience support the activities of our boards and agencies, yet are required by the Discipline "To lead the congregation in the fulfillment of its mission through full and faithful payment of all apportioned ministerial support, administrative, and benevolent funds" [Para. 331.2(3)f].

It is faithful and godly men and women the caliber of Charles Sineath, Connie Roland Alt, Andy Vom Steeg, Tom Tanner, Edward Ezaki and Kevin Clancey whom we cannot afford to lose. Yet, they have all been lost because their pleas for biblical fidelity, accountability and fairness have been ignored by persons in leadership positions. However, those same "leaders," such as Melvin Talbert, Joseph Sprague and yourself, have supported and defended the rebellious actions of such persons as Jimmy Creech, Greg Dell and Don Fado. These persons are a disgrace to United Methodism and our denomination would be much better off without them and without those who shamelessly support and defend them.

I doubt there will be any disciplinary action initiated against you by the Council of Bishops, although such action would be entirely appropriate. I must be content, therefore, to inform you by this letter that neither I nor a significant number of United Methodists throughout our connection can continue to recognize you as a bishop.

With deepest regrets,


James A. Gibson III

Dennis "Buck" Linton-Hendrick, Pastor-Wallace and Grainton UM Parish, NE
Jake Barker, FUMC, Checotah Checotah, OK
Tom Graffagnino, Hamilton UMC, Hamilton, GA
Joe McManus Austin, TX
Karen Covey Moore
Tim Paulk
Russell K. Fitch
Mike or Carmen Gordon
Becky Bozic, Central UMC, Fairmont, WV
Rev. David Fowler, Gothenburg United Methodist Church, Gothenburg, NE
Pastor C. William Bicket, Banner & Brady United Methodist Churches, Gothenburg & Brady, NE
Allen O. Morris, MBA, Executive Director, Concerned Methodists, Inc., Fayetteville, NC
William J. Hurst, pastor, Lacon Sparland United Methodist Church, IL
James Driskel
Don Thompson, Christ UMC, Memphis TN
Rev. John Warrener, Palmyra Road UMC, Albany GA

Click to Add  your endorsement to this letter below
or write to

Carolyn B. Shearouse, <>, Andrew UMC, Kathleen, GA USA -

Rev. William H. Gardner, <je5u5@bellsouth,net>, Sweetwater U.M.C., Pearson, GA USA -

Rev. Roy E. Jacobsen, <>, Trinity United Methodist Church, Windsor, CT USA -

Rev. David O. Moehring, South Camden Charge, Camden, NC USA -

Milton Lynch, Nichols UMC, Nichols, NY USA -

Joan Ritta, lst UMC, Heber Springs, AR USA -

H. Dwight Bishop, Sr., <>, Glennville UMC, glennville, Ga USA -

Pauline Hord, <>, Christ UMC, Memphis, Memphis, TN USA -

John W. Presley, White Oak UMC, USA -

Rev. Jeffrey Foster, <>, Hohenwald Circuit United Methodist Church, Hohenwald, TN USA -

Clayton D. Harriger, <>, Retired Elder in Full Connection - W. Pa. Annual Conference of the UMC, Belsano, PA USA -

Rev. Bill Lichlyter, <>, Chestnut Grove / Ebenezer, Talbott, TN USA -

Rev. Carson Daniel Lauffer, <>, Retired Elder, NIC, Crest Hill, Ill USA -

Richard Dalfiume, <>, Nichols UMC, Nichols, NY USA -

Richard A. Newton, <>, Grace United Methodist, Tifton, Ga USA -

Janz I. Mynderup - H.I.S. VisionMinistries, <>, St Luke's UMC - Ocassionally, Now...., Fresno, CA USA -

Sally Warrener, <>, PRUMC, Albany, GA USA -

[Click] button If you would like to add your yourcomments.gif (1566 bytes) to the UCM News

<Back to News

Script modified by script created by Matt Wright and can be found at Matt's Script Archive